Soft, chewy chocolate chip cookies with a delicious twist! These strawberry chocolate chip cookies take the best of your favorite cookie and infuses them with a delightful chocolate-covered strawberry taste! This is a sponsored collaboration with Domino® Sugar.
These ingredients are very similar to my favorite chocolate chip cookies, with just a few adjustments.
- Flour – Use all-purpose flour for the best results. I wouldn’t use cake flour as the addition of the arrowroot starch makes the cookies take on a similar texture that cake flour would give, but with a bit more sturdiness. Bread flour would weigh down the cookies too much and with the strawberries, make them dense and tough.
- Cornstarch – This is my secret ingredient to soft cookies that stay soft. You can find it in most of your grocery stores – usually in the gluten-free or baking aisles.
- Baking soda – This gives our strawberry chocolate chip cookies rise and a nice puffiness
- Salt – I like to use sea salt for the best results. It enhances the flavors in the cookie and really helps the strawberry flavor pop!
- Freeze-dried strawberries – Freeze-dried strawberries are completely compacted with flavor and go a long way into infusing the cookies with a deep fresh strawberry flavor and a delicate pink color.
- Butter – You should always use unsalted butter in your baking, and this is no exception. My favorite part about this recipe is that we use melted butter, so no need to worry about remembering to take the butter out to soften.
- Sugar – We use a combination of Domino® Golden Sugar and Domino® Light Brown Sugar. I love their sugar because it is so high quality and gives the cookies the perfect texture. The Golden Sugar is less processed than your typical granulated sugar and therefore has a mouthwatering subtle note of molasses. It works cup for cup like granulated sugar, so you can easily use it in all your favorite bakes. The light brown sugar helps deepen that molasses flavor, adds a note of caramel, and makes the cookies nice and chewy.
- Eggs – Use large eggs. We only need one egg, plus one egg yolk. The extra yolk adds more richness to the cookies, plus more moisture which is needed with the addition of the strawberries.
- Vanilla – I like to add vanilla to bring a touch of strawberries and cream to the cookies. It also rounds out all the flavors and adds depth.
- Chocolate – The chocolate adds so much delicious decadence to the cookies. I usually like to use dark chocolate, but I’ve found it is too much when paired with the strawberries. Instead, I recommend a mix of semi-sweet and milk chocolate – or just one of them. We also use less chocolate than normal. A little goes a long way here.
What I love about these strawberry chocolate chip cookies is that you don’t have to use a mixer. I tend to use my mixer because that is what I instinctively reach for when baking, but you don’t have to! It mixes perfectly by hand.
- The first step is to make powdered strawberry. All we need to do is crush your freeze-dried strawberries until they resemble a fine powder. You can do this in any number of ways, but my preference is the food processor. I always like to make a bit extra because it allows us to be able to add more if we want to have a ton of extra flavor. It can also be used for decorating the cookies.
- Now, we need to melt the butter. I usually do this in the microwave because it’s faster. My trick is to cube the butter and then microwave it to speed up the process even more.
- Take the butter and add the Domino® sugars and vanilla to it. Their sugar incorporates beautifully with the melted butter which is why I absolutely love it for getting the light and fluffy texture we are looking for once we start beating them together.
- Add in the egg and beat until it lightens. It may take a few minutes and it shouldn’t be dramatically lighter in color, so don’t worry if it doesn’t lighten up a ton.
- At this point, we need to take all the dry ingredients: the flour, leavening, salt, and strawberry powder and mix them together until they are fully combined. Super simple.
- Add the flour mix into the butter and stir just until it is mixed in. You can do this by hand or with your mixer. I like to do it by hand when I can, but the mixer is definitely easier.
- Fold in the chocolate, but save some for the tops of your cookies. Trust me on this, it is how we get them to look absolutely mouthwatering.
- Cover the cookie dough and chill for at least 30 minutes, but the longer, the better. It gives the flavors a chance to really intermingle. Go ahead and preheat the oven as soon as you are ready to bake. Once you’ve done that, portion out the cookie dough and top them with the extra chocolate we saved.
- Bake the cookies up and enjoy!
Don’t skip the arrowroot starch if possible. It helps keep the cookies nice and soft and thick.
Make sure the egg and yolk are room temperature. It helps to keep the eggs (still in their shell) in a bowl of very warm water. It will bring up the temperature of the eggs to room temperature within a couple of minutes.
Don’t heat the butter until it becomes brown butter. Normally, brown butter in cookies is delicious, but the flavor of the brown butter would overwhelm the strawberries here. This is why I recommend melting the butter in the microwave.
Fluff your flour before measuring it, and then use a spoon to fill your measuring cup – or use weight measurements. This helps to ensure that you aren’t adding too much flour to your cookies which would make them thick, dense blobs.
Use Domino® Sugar! If you want the best cookies, you need the best ingredients, starting with the sugar.
The strawberry chocolate chip cookies will be slightly underbaked when you take them out. That is how we keep them soft. Leave them on the hot baking sheet when you remove them from the oven. It will allow the cookies to cook a little longer and let them set enough for you to transfer them to a wire rack.
I find the culprit for puffy cookies that don’t flatten as the cool is too much flour. It is important that the flour is carefully measured because of the strawberry powder. Freeze-dried strawberries want to hydrate when introduced to liquid, so they are absorbing a lot of the liquid. Any excess flour will end up binding and holding the cookies together and not allowing them to spread properly.
Unfortunately, the amount of fresh strawberries you’d need to flavor the cookies would add too much liquid and make the cookies cakey.
Dried strawberries are different from freeze-dried strawberries and are closer to dried cranberries. It will give a jammy strawberry flavor when you bite into it, but will not permeate the cookies with a fresh strawberry flavor.
You can find freeze-dried strawberries in most grocery stores.